Helium vs. Oxygen

Property	Helium	Oxygen
Chemical Symbol	He	O
Atomic Number	2	8
Density at Room Temperature	0.1786 kg/m³ (Gas)	1.429 kg/m³ (Gas)
State at Room Temperature	Gas	Gas
Usage and Applications	– Cryogenics for cooling	– Vital for sustaining life
	– Inflating balloons	– Supports combustion
	– Shielding gas in welding	– Industrial applications
	– Deep-sea diving (heliox)	– Rocket propulsion (liquid oxygen)
Biological Importance	None	Essential for aerobic respiration
Environmental Impact	Inert, no environmental impact	Can support combustion, may have environmental impact in large-scale production
Purity and Production	Extracted as a byproduct of natural gas	Produced through fractional distillation of air
Health and Safety Considerations	Inhaling directly from pressurized tanks can be dangerous	Must be handled with care to prevent combustion hazards
Special Gas Mixtures	Heliox (helium-oxygen mixtures for deep-sea diving)	Oxygen-enriched air (nitrox for scuba diving)
Atmospheric Presence	Trace element in Earth’s atmosphere	Constitutes about 21% of the Earth’s atmosphere
Role in Combustion	Does not support combustion	Essential for combustion reactions
Isotopes	Helium-3 (³He) and Helium-4 (⁴He)	Oxygen-16 (¹⁶O), Oxygen-17 (¹⁷O), and Oxygen-18 (¹⁸O)
Gas Laws and Behavior	Follows ideal gas law, predictable behavior	Follows ideal gas law, well-understood behavior
Use in Aerospace	Used for buoyancy in airships and balloons	Used as an oxidizer in rocket propulsion systems
Hazards and Safety Precautions	Direct inhalation can lead to oxygen deprivation	Must be handled carefully to prevent combustion
Gas Storage and Handling	Stored in high-pressure cylinders or cryogenic containers	Stored in high-pressure cylinders with precautions
Production for Industrial Use	Produced as a byproduct of natural gas extraction	Produced through fractional distillation of air
Gas Mixture for Deep-Sea Diving	Heliox (helium-oxygen mixture)	Not used in deep-sea diving
Gas Mixture for Scuba Diving	Not used in scuba diving	Oxygen-enriched air (nitrox) used to extend dive times

Think of helium as the light-hearted, buoyant party guest that makes balloons dance effortlessly above our heads. On the other hand, oxygen is the reliable, life-sustaining friend, always present in the background, fueling the fires of life. So, what sets these gases apart? What makes one essential for breathing and the other a key player in making balloons defy gravity?

Differences Between Helium and Oxygen

The main differences between Helium and Oxygen lie in their properties, applications, and significance. Helium is an inert, light gas with a low density, often used in cryogenics and for inflating balloons, whereas Oxygen is essential for life, supports combustion, and finds application in medical treatments and rocket propulsion. Understanding these disparities is key to appreciating how these two elemental gases play vastly different roles in our world.

1. Chemical Composition and Properties

Helium:

Helium, symbolized as He on the periodic table, is a colorless, odorless, and tasteless gas. It’s the second lightest and the second most abundant element in the universe. Helium is a noble gas, which means it’s inert and doesn’t readily react with other elements. This quality makes it safe for various applications, especially in its gaseous state.

In its natural form, helium is extracted from underground reservoirs, primarily in the United States. The primary usage of helium lies in its liquid form, which is achieved at extremely low temperatures. Liquid helium is critical in cryogenic applications, such as cooling superconducting magnets in MRI machines and scientific research. It’s also famous for its role in inflating balloons, making them float.

Oxygen:

Oxygen, denoted as O on the periodic table, is a reactive, colorless, tasteless, and odorless gas. Unlike helium, oxygen is essential for human survival. It comprises around 21% of the Earth’s atmosphere, making it a crucial component for supporting life. Oxygen is highly reactive and readily combines with other elements, especially in the process of combustion.

Oxygen is typically produced through various methods, including fractional distillation of air and electrolysis of water. Its primary purpose is to sustain life, as it is required for cellular respiration in humans and other aerobic organisms. Oxygen therapy is a common medical application, helping patients with respiratory issues get the vital oxygen they need.

2. Density and State at Room Temperature

Helium: Helium is incredibly light. It’s less dense than air, which is why helium-filled balloons float. At room temperature (around 20°C or 68°F), helium remains in a gaseous state. It has a very low density, approximately 0.1786 kg/m³, making it much lighter than air. This low density allows helium to lift objects, such as balloons, and even airships.

Oxygen: Oxygen, on the other hand, is denser than helium. At room temperature, it also exists in a gaseous state. It has a density of approximately 1.429 kg/m³, which is significantly higher than that of helium. This density is a reason why oxygen doesn’t lift objects like helium but plays a crucial role in supporting combustion and sustaining life.

Let’s take a closer look at their densities in the following table:

Property	Helium	Oxygen
Density	0.1786 kg/m³	1.429 kg/m³
State at Room Temperature	Gas	Gas

3. Usage and Applications

Helium: Helium has a range of applications owing to its unique properties. Some of its primary uses include:

• Cryogenics: Liquid helium is used in cryogenic applications, cooling superconducting magnets in MRI machines, and enabling low-temperature scientific experiments.
• Balloons: Helium-filled balloons are common at parties and events due to their ability to float, adding a festive atmosphere.
• Welding: Helium is often used as a shielding gas in welding processes, ensuring a stable and consistent arc.
• Diving: In deep-sea diving, helium-oxygen gas mixtures, known as heliox, help reduce the risk of decompression sickness.

Oxygen: Oxygen is indispensable for life on Earth and has a variety of applications, including:

• Medical Use: Oxygen therapy is essential for patients with respiratory problems. It’s administered in hospitals and can be used at home under medical supervision.
• Combustion: Oxygen supports combustion and is vital for various industrial processes, such as metal smelting and cutting.
• Aerospace: Rockets and spacecraft require oxygen for propulsion and life support systems. Liquid oxygen is often used as rocket propellant.
• Scuba Diving: In recreational diving, compressed air or oxygen-enriched air (nitrox) is used to sustain underwater breathing.

4. Biological Importance

Helium: Helium does not have any known biological significance. It does not participate in chemical reactions essential for life processes and is not involved in respiration.

Oxygen: Oxygen is critically important for most living organisms, including humans. It plays a central role in the process of aerobic respiration. In this metabolic process, oxygen is used by cells to generate energy from nutrients. Without a constant supply of oxygen, human and animal life cannot be sustained.

5. Environmental Impact

Helium: Helium is considered environmentally inert. Being a noble gas, it doesn’t readily combine with other elements to form compounds, and it doesn’t pose any environmental hazards. However, helium is a finite resource, and concerns about helium scarcity have been raised due to the limited availability of natural helium reserves.

Oxygen: Oxygen is a component of the Earth’s atmosphere and is vital for life. However, in excessive amounts, it can support combustion, which poses a fire hazard. It’s also important to note that oxygen generation for industrial purposes can have environmental impacts, especially when large amounts are produced using energy-intensive methods.

6. Purity and Production

Helium: Helium is often produced as a byproduct of natural gas extraction. The primary source of commercial helium is the United States, with the Federal Helium Reserve in Texas being a significant supplier. The extraction process involves cryogenic distillation, where natural gas is cooled to separate helium from other gases.

Helium purity is essential for various applications, particularly in scientific research and medical settings. Ultra-high purity helium, with minimal impurities, is necessary for maintaining the superconductivity of magnets in MRI machines and other scientific instruments.

Oxygen: Oxygen is primarily obtained by separating it from air. This can be done through a process called fractional distillation, where air is cooled and compressed, allowing different components like nitrogen and argon to be separated from oxygen. Another method involves the electrolysis of water, yielding highly pure oxygen.

Oxygen purity is crucial, especially in medical applications. Medical-grade oxygen must meet specific purity standards to ensure the safety and health of patients. Industrial oxygen, used in processes like metal cutting, may have lower purity requirements.

7. Health and Safety Considerations

Helium: Helium is generally safe for human health. Inhaling helium in small amounts, such as when speaking with a helium-filled balloon, is not harmful. However, inhaling helium from pressurized tanks directly can be dangerous, as it can displace oxygen in the lungs, leading to oxygen deprivation and potentially asphyxiation.

Oxygen: Oxygen is essential for human life, and oxygen therapy is commonly used in medical settings to treat various respiratory conditions. However, the use of oxygen also comes with certain safety considerations. Oxygen supports combustion, so it should be handled with care, especially in the presence of flammable materials or open flames.

8. Special Gaseous Mixtures

Heliox: Heliox is a mixture of helium and oxygen. It is used in specific applications where the advantages of helium’s low density are combined with the necessity of oxygen for breathing. Common examples include deep-sea diving and medical treatments for patients with severe respiratory issues.

The composition of heliox can vary depending on the intended use. For deep-sea diving, mixtures with higher helium content are used to reduce the risk of nitrogen narcosis, a condition caused by breathing high-pressure nitrogen at great depths.

Oxygen-Enriched Air: Oxygen-enriched air, often referred to as nitrox, is a mixture of nitrogen and oxygen where the oxygen content is higher than the 21% found in normal air. It is used in scuba diving to extend the time divers can spend underwater without the need for decompression stops. By adjusting the oxygen content, divers can reduce the risk of decompression sickness.

9. Transportation and Storage

Helium: Transporting and storing helium is relatively straightforward. It is typically compressed into cylinders or tanks and can be safely stored and transported in its gaseous or liquid form. Liquid helium is often stored in specialized cryogenic containers.

Oxygen: Transporting and storing oxygen requires careful consideration due to its role in supporting combustion. Oxygen cylinders must be securely stored, and they are often color-coded to distinguish them from other gases. Special precautions are taken to prevent leaks and ensure the safety of handling and storage.

10. Cost and Availability

Helium: Helium is considered a relatively expensive gas due to the energy-intensive processes required to extract and refine it. Additionally, concerns about helium scarcity have led to fluctuations in its availability and pricing.

Oxygen: Oxygen is abundant and relatively inexpensive. It is a major component of the Earth’s atmosphere, and methods for its production are well-established, contributing to its affordability and widespread availability.

11. Chemical Reactions and Reactivity

Helium: Helium is a noble gas, which means it is chemically inert. It does not readily form compounds with other elements, and it does not participate in chemical reactions under normal conditions. This inertness makes it a safe and stable gas for various applications.

Oxygen: Oxygen is highly reactive. It readily combines with other elements, and its participation in combustion reactions is well-known. It is essential for various chemical reactions, particularly those involving the release of energy through combustion processes.

12. Symbol and Atomic Number

Helium: Symbol: He Atomic Number: 2

Oxygen: Symbol: O Atomic Number: 8

13. Gas Laws and Behavior

Helium: Helium follows the ideal gas law, which describes its behavior at various temperatures and pressures. As a noble gas, it behaves predictably and exhibits low viscosity, making it suitable for applications where gas flow and diffusion are essential.

Oxygen: Oxygen also follows the ideal gas law, and its behavior under different conditions is well-understood. It has a higher viscosity compared to helium, which affects its flow characteristics.

14. Atmospheric Presence

Helium: Helium is a trace element in the Earth’s atmosphere, with a concentration of about 5.2 parts per million (ppm) by volume. It is released into the atmosphere through natural gas extraction but is not a significant component of the air we breathe.

Oxygen: Oxygen is a vital component of the Earth’s atmosphere, constituting approximately 21% of the air. This concentration is necessary to support human and animal respiration, as well as combustion processes.

15. Role in Combustion

Helium: Helium does not support combustion. It is inert and does not react with other elements, making it unsuitable for combustion-related applications.

Oxygen: Oxygen is a key component for combustion. It sustains the chemical reaction between a fuel source and oxygen, leading to the release of energy and heat. This property is crucial for a wide range of industrial processes, from heating to metal smelting.

16. Use in Aerospace

Helium: Helium is used in aerospace for its low density. It has been historically used to provide buoyancy in airships and balloons. However, due to its limited supply and the expense of helium, alternatives like hydrogen have been explored for some applications.

Oxygen: Oxygen plays a vital role in aerospace. It is used as an oxidizer in rocket propulsion systems. Liquid oxygen, when combined with rocket fuels, supports combustion, creating the thrust required for space exploration and satellite launches.

17. Hazards and Safety Precautions

Helium: Helium, in itself, is not hazardous. However, inhaling helium directly from a pressurized source can be dangerous. It can displace oxygen in the lungs, leading to oxygen deprivation and potentially asphyxiation. Care should be taken when using helium in its gaseous form to ensure proper ventilation.

Oxygen: Oxygen, while essential for life, can be hazardous when handled improperly. It supports combustion, so it should be kept away from open flames, flammable materials, and sources of ignition. Oxygen cylinders should be stored and transported in an upright and secure manner to prevent leaks or damage.

18. Isotopes

Helium: Helium has two stable isotopes: helium-3 (³He) and helium-4 (⁴He). Helium-4 is the more common and abundant isotope and is used in most applications.

Oxygen: Oxygen has three stable isotopes: oxygen-16 (¹⁶O), oxygen-17 (¹⁷O), and oxygen-18 (¹⁸O). These isotopes have slightly different masses and are used in various scientific and medical applications, such as stable isotope analysis.

19. Gas Storage and Handling

Helium: Helium is typically stored and transported in high-pressure cylinders or cryogenic containers when in its liquid form. It should be handled with care to prevent leaks and ensure safety.

Oxygen: Oxygen is also stored in high-pressure cylinders but must be managed with greater care due to its reactivity. Special precautions are taken to minimize the risk of combustion during storage and handling.

20. Production for Industrial Use

Helium: Helium is produced primarily as a byproduct of natural gas extraction. The extraction process involves cryogenic distillation, which cools natural gas to separate helium from other gases.

Oxygen: Oxygen for industrial use is often produced through the fractional distillation of air. Air is compressed and cooled, allowing different components to be separated, with oxygen being one of the primary products.

21. Gas Mixture for Deep-Sea Diving

Heliox: Heliox, a mixture of helium and oxygen, is used in deep-sea diving to reduce the risk of nitrogen narcosis. It allows divers to withstand high pressures at great depths without experiencing the negative effects of breathing high-pressure nitrogen.

22. Gas Mixture for Scuba Diving

Oxygen-Enriched Air (Nitrox): Nitrox is a gas mixture used in scuba diving that contains a higher percentage of oxygen than normal air. It allows divers to extend their dive times without the need for lengthy decompression stops, making it a popular choice for recreational divers.

In conclusion, helium and oxygen are two distinct gases with diverse properties, applications, and significance. Helium, with its low density and inertness, finds use in cryogenics, balloons, and welding. Oxygen, essential for life and combustion, has a wide range of applications in medicine, industry, and aerospace. Understanding these differences is vital for safely and effectively utilizing these gases in various fields, from healthcare to scientific research, and even deep-sea exploration.

FAQs

Read More:

• Oxygen vs Hydrogen
• SSI vs PADI
• Reduction vs Oxidation
• Gaseous State vs Liquid State
• Vapor vs Gas